The use of surveillance cameras in public spaces and the power of the president to detain individuals suspected of terrorism will be among the topics explored when the American Moot Court Association's Eastern Regional tournament is held this week at Fitchburg State University.
Students competing in moot court argue both sides of a hypothetical legal case before panels of judges, simulating an appellate court proceeding.
Professor Paul I. Weizer of the university’s Economics, History and Political Science Department has coached the university’s Moot Court program since its inception. The program has a strong history of sending teams to advanced rounds of the national tournament, including high scores for students drafting legal briefs on the case before them.
Fitchburg State is one of 18 schools to host regional tournaments nationwide.
“I am always proud to show off our excellent facilities and bring back so many alumni and members of the local legal community to serve as judges,” said Weizer.
The list of schools competing in this regional include: Bentley University, Berea College, Boston University, Brown University, Cal-State Fullerton, Emerson College, Fitchburg State University, Framingham State University, Liberty University, Merrimack College, University at Albany, University of Connecticut, University of Pennsylvania, the University of Washington, and Western Connecticut State University.
Students will argue before real judges and lawyers in this competition, demonstrating the ability to present a multifaceted, complex legal argument, to think on their feet, to respond to questions, and to respond under duress.
Fitchburg State has had tremendous success in past Eastern Regional competitions. In 2002, Keith Greiner and Lauren McGuirk won the championship, and last year the team of Amanda DeLeon Guimares and Christiane Rodrigues secured victory.
“Last year was a tremendous experience,” said Weizer. “But we start each new season with a clean slate. The competition is very tough and there are many strong programs coming to Fitchburg. But I have great confidence in our process and feel that we will be very competitive.”
Rodrigues returns to lead the Falcons and defend the Eastern Regional title. She will be partnered with Nathan Howard.
“Nathan will be competing in his second season,” said Weizer. “He has improved dramatically over the last year. It was a very competitive process to determine our team pairings. But, Nathan and Christiane clearly distinguished themselves. Chris, Nathan, and Lexi Sandmann served as team captains this year. Each brought valuable experience and were very generous with their time to serve as mentors to the first-time competitors.”
Rodrigues admits that the pressure is on, but she’s trying not to focus too much on it or defending the title.
“What I'm most excited about is representing Fitchburg State and defending our school's name,” said Rodrigues. “It's such an honor to compete against other schools, and I genuinely believe that everyone on our team right now has what it takes to win. I'm especially excited about seeing how far we've come as a team. When you think about everything that goes into this competition, it's incredible. We're memorizing over 20 cases, court splits, articles, statutory sections, laws, and arguments. We're learning to identify legal issues, understand different judicial opinions, and defend arguments in front of judges. It's not something you can accomplish overnight. It's months of preparation, studying, and pushing ourselves.”
Rodrigues – a First Generation student – says she’s honestly just excited to get back on the podium.
“There's something so rewarding about seeing all those hours of preparation come together,” she said. “But more than anything, I'm excited to represent Fitchburg State University, compete alongside my teammates, and show everyone what our school is capable of.”
Rodrigues can’t thank Weizer enough for all he does to get each student prepared, and how much he cares about each of his students.
“Professor Weizer is amazing,” said Rodrigues. “He genuinely wants to see us succeed. He wants to see us do our best, and he never lets us settle for less than what he knows we're capable of. Every class, he challenges us to improve. He'll ask us if we can do better, point out areas where our arguments need work, and push us to reach our full potential.
“Something I especially appreciate is how much he trusts his students,” said Rodrigues. “He gives us the confidence to stand in front of judges, argue complicated legal issues, and compete against other schools. He doesn't just teach us the material; he makes sure we understand it, know how to apply it, and can defend it when we're challenged. I'm not really a sports girl, but if I were, I would say professor Weizer is the best coach of all time. In fact, I think we should give him a new title: GCOAT — Greatest Coach of All Time.”
Fitchburg State’s teams are: Howard/Rodrigues, Cammie Crawford/Mariah Garcia, Nigel O'Neill/Alexis Sandmann, and Adeline Van Hazinga/Nilmarys Santos Torres.
Learn more about the tournament, and view the full text of this year’s case problem, at https://www.amcamootcourt.org/about.